11 min readUpdated October 2026For the Craft

Growing Masonic lodges are not lucky, and they are not in better neighborhoods. They share a short list of habits: they answer every man who asks, they walk each candidate through the degrees with a mentor, they make meetings worth attending, they stay in touch with every member, they are visible in their towns, and they let younger men lead. Grand Lodge research from Ohio, New York, Virginia, Kentucky, and California points to the same habits, and none of them needs a large budget.

Picture two lodges 10 miles apart. Same Grand Lodge, same dues, similar buildings, similar towns. One raises a handful of men every year and fills the room on stated meeting night. The other reads a longer list of losses every December and wonders where everyone went.

The difference is rarely the town. It is usually what happens after a man fills in the form, after he is initiated, and after he is raised. That part is entirely within a lodge’s control.

Below are the habits that keep showing up in the research, what the evidence for each one actually says, and how a lodge can copy them.

A Note on the EvidenceVery few individual lodges publish their membership figures, so most of the evidence here comes from Grand Lodge programs, member surveys, and retention studies. Where a source reports results, we give the numbers. Where it reports judgment and experience, we say so.

The Short List

Six habits come up again and again. Each one closes a specific gap where lodges lose men.

Habit What the evidence shows Source
Answer every inquiry A structured follow-up turns about 58 percent of leads into prospects Grand Lodge of Ohio, via Scottish Rite NMJ
Mentor every candidate The biggest drop comes between the first and second degrees, from 87 to 69 percent Grand Lodge of Ohio, via Scottish Rite NMJ
Make meetings worth attending Programming called “the single most important factor” in retention Grand Lodge of New York
Stay in touch with everyone 96 percent of surveyed members wanted consistent communication William O. Ware Lodge of Research
Be visible in town Open houses, tours, and community breakfasts listed among what successful lodges do Grand Lodge of New York
Let young men lead About 65 California masters in 2021 to 2022 were under 40 California Freemason

Each habit is covered in more detail below, with the full sources listed at the end.

1. They Answer Every Man Who Asks

The first habit is the simplest and the most often missed. Scottish Rite research found that 83 percent of men who inquired through its national portal never heard back from a lodge or Grand Lodge. Growing lodges are the ones that answer.

Ohio built a process around it. According to a Scottish Rite NMJ case study, the Grand Lodge sends each new lead “one email a week for nine weeks,” and each of its 25 districts has a prospect manager who receives the man’s details. About 58 percent of leads become prospects, and about 17 percent of prospects become petitioners. California reports that about 10 percent of more than 13,000 online prospects have become Masons.

A single lodge can do the same thing on a smaller scale: an automatic reply within minutes, a named brother who calls within days, and an invitation to dinner. The full approach is in The Follow-Up Most Lodges Never Send.

2. They Walk Each Candidate Through the Degrees

The Ohio figures reveal where most men are actually lost. After petitioning, 87 percent become Entered Apprentices, but “the number drops to 69% of men who progress to Fellowcraft.” Of the men who complete the second degree, 90 percent go on to become Master Masons. The leak is the gap between the first and second degrees.

That is the gap a mentor closes. The Grand Lodge of Virginia’s retention tool kit recommends assigning a coach or mentor for each degree and asks lodges to “make certain a member calls the new member prior to each meeting.” It lists the reasons new Masons give for drifting away: no time, a lodge that did not meet their expectations, no contact after the degree, and an unfriendly lodge. Two of those four are about whether anyone reached out.

A new man’s first year in a lodge that keeps its members

The week he asksAn acknowledgment the same day, a call from a named brother within days, and an invitation to dinner before anything formal.
Before the first degreeHe meets members socially. New York’s guidance says early steps should “help form the bonds of friendship and increase retention.”
Each degreeA coach or mentor works with him, and the Master checks in with that mentor, as Virginia recommends.
Between degreesSomeone calls him before every meeting. This is the gap where Ohio loses the most men.
After he is raisedHe gets a job in the lodge right away. British Columbia’s study of successful lodges urges involving new members in “ritual work, festive board socials, and projects, as soon as possible.”
The first yearRegular contact continues. Ohio keeps sending onboarding emails monthly for a year after a man becomes a Master Mason.

New York has put a name to the role. Its NorthStar program trains “Success Coaches” for new brothers, and the Grand Lodge’s Membership Development Committee noted that more than 120 lodges still lacked one, which it said limited their access to retention tools.

3. Their Meetings Are Worth Attending

A man who gives up an evening a month needs a reason to come back. The New York report put it bluntly: “Quality and Masonic focus in programming remains the single most important factor when it comes to membership retention.”

Kentucky’s members said much the same when asked what an ideal lodge looks like. The William O. Ware Lodge of Research surveyed 476 members from 202 lodges in 2019.

What Kentucky members said an ideal lodge emphasizes

Consistent communication with members96 percent
Proficient ritual delivery93 percent
Charity for Masons in need82 percent
Public charity and fundraising76 percent
Quality meals at lodge64 percent

Share of respondents who agreed with each characteristic. Most respondents were current or past Masters, and the authors caution that the sample is hard to generalize from.

Lodges that take this seriously tend to do a few things. They keep routine business short; California says its LodgeCraft tool can cut routine business in some lodges “from 30 minutes to 10.” They offer some education at every meeting. And they eat well together. Andrew Hammer’s widely shared Eight Steps to Excellence argues that a lodge “must offer quality assemblies and be willing to pay for them,” adding that “excess is not the objective; quality is.”

Formality appeals to more younger men than many lodges expect. California Freemason profiled Home No. 721, which follows a traditional observance style with tuxedos at lodge dinners, and quoted its young Master saying younger members tend to favor the formal side of Masonry (California Freemason, 2022).

4. They Stay in Touch With Every Member

Most lodges have far more men on the rolls than in the room. The Kentucky study found that 56 percent of men on lodge rolls had not meaningfully participated since their most recent degree, and it estimated that only about 6 percent were actively engaged. Those men are not gone yet. They are waiting to be asked.

Growing lodges keep a steady line of contact: a monthly email or newsletter, calls to brothers who have stopped coming, and birthday and holiday notes. British Columbia’s study of successful lodges noted that in some of them the “incoming Master communicates individually with each member of the lodge before he is installed” (Grand Lodge of British Columbia and Yukon).

Dues are part of staying in touch. California began handling dues invoicing centrally for lodges that opt in, and more than 200 lodges joined. On average, participating lodges see 80 percent of members pay on time, and the Grand Lodge says the program means “fewer suspensions” (The Leader, October 2024). Its 2025 report credits “improved dues collection that has sharply reduced suspensions” as part of the year it grew for the first time in 60 years (2025 Fraternity Report).

Want the basics handled for your lodge? Our foundation projects set up the website, Business Profile, inquiry follow-up, and member email list in one engagement, with your lodge holding every key.

See foundation projects

5. They Are Visible in Their Towns

A man cannot ask to join a lodge he has never heard of. Growing lodges make sure their neighbors know they exist.

The New York report describes what its successful lodges do: they recognize community members, partner with service clubs, sports leagues, and the Shrine, and hold “open houses, Lodge tours, and community breakfasts.” It also reported what a modest online push produced. A social media campaign costing $17,529 reached 935,462 men, drew 18,546 website visits, and produced more than 425 information requests and 63 new Master Masons within a year. Initiates in the state rose from 781 in 2018 to 907 in 2019.

The report was careful to add that social media is “not a silver bullet that will fix our retention issues.” Visibility brings men to the door. The other habits keep them inside. The groundwork for being found locally is in Setting Up Your Lodge’s Google Business Profile and What Lodge Social Media Has to Do to Work.

6. They Let Younger Men Lead

Lodges that grow tend to hand responsibility to new members quickly, including the chair in the East. California Freemason reported that about 65 California lodge masters in 2021 to 2022 were under 40, including eight in their twenties. The average age of prospects reaching the Grand Lodge was 36.

Younger officers often bring practical changes. At Home No. 721, one young Master set up a Slack channel where members and prospects can talk and ask questions, saying it is “a great way to keep everyone in the loop.” In Pennsylvania, Masons who serve as DeMolay advisors have helped bring a run of young men into lodges; the Pennsylvania Freemason counted 12 “DeMolay Masons” in its 2025 report on the trend. Pennsylvania DeMolay’s executive officer urged Masons to visit chapters, learn the young men’s names, and invite them to lodge events, saying “It is crucial to take the time to build relationships with these young men” (Pennsylvania Freemason).

What None of Them Needed

Look back over the six habits and notice what is missing. None of them requires a large budget, a new building, or a paid recruitment campaign. Each one costs time and attention from a few brothers who decide it matters.

That is good news for a small lodge. A lodge of 40 members can answer every inquiry, assign a mentor to every candidate, put some education on every agenda, call the brothers who have drifted, hold an open house, and give a new Master Mason a real job. Those are the same things the growing lodges are doing.

The Lodge Someone Decided to Keep

Every growing lodge has a story behind it, and it usually starts with a few brothers who decided their lodge was worth the effort. One of them started answering the inquiry emails. Another started calling the men who had stopped coming. Someone put a short paper on the agenda and a decent meal on the table.

None of that shows up in a membership report at first. A few years later it does. The lodges that are growing did not wait for the decline to reverse itself. They made their own lodge the kind a man wants to join and does not want to leave.

In Short

1

Growing lodges answer every inquiry quickly and run a real prospect process, as Ohio and California do at the state level.

2

They assign a mentor to every candidate and call him between degrees, where Ohio’s data shows most men are lost.

3

They hold meetings worth attending, stay in touch with every member, stay visible in town, and give younger men real responsibility.

Questions Brothers Ask

01

What do growing Masonic lodges do differently?

They answer every inquiry quickly, assign a mentor to every candidate, hold meetings with real Masonic content, stay in regular contact with every member, stay visible in their communities, and give younger members responsibility early. Grand Lodge research from Ohio, New York, Virginia, Kentucky, and California points to the same habits.

02

Where do lodges lose most new members?

Between the first and second degrees. Ohio’s figures show 87 percent of petitioners become Entered Apprentices, but only 69 percent progress to Fellowcraft. Of those who complete the second degree, 90 percent become Master Masons. A mentor and regular calls between degrees close that gap.

03

Does a lodge need a big budget to grow?

No. The habits that show up in the research cost time rather than money: answering inquiries, mentoring candidates, planning good meetings, and keeping in touch with members. New York’s social media campaign cost $17,529 for the whole state and produced 63 new Master Masons within a year.

04

Why does mentoring matter so much?

Because new Masons who drift away often say nobody contacted them after their degree or the lodge felt unfriendly. The Grand Lodge of Virginia recommends a coach or mentor for each degree and a call to the new member before every meeting.

05

Do younger men want formal, traditional lodges?

Many do. California Freemason profiled lodges led by Masters in their twenties, including one that follows a traditional observance style with tuxedos at lodge dinners, and its Master said younger members tend to favor the formal side of Masonry. Kentucky members also rated proficient ritual very highly.

06

What is the first habit a lodge should adopt?

Answering every inquiry. Scottish Rite research found 83 percent of men who inquired online never heard back. Name one brother to reply within days, set up an automatic acknowledgment, and invite every man to dinner before anything formal.

Sources

  1. Scottish Rite, NMJ, Grand Lodge of Ohio growth case study.
  2. Scottish Rite, NMJ, Millennials and Freemasonry.
  3. Grand Lodge of New York, Membership Development Committee report, covering 2019 and 2020.
  4. Grand Lodge of Virginia, 2009 Membership Retention Tool Kit.
  5. William O. Ware Lodge of Research, Characteristics of an Ideal Lodge: Survey Results and Analysis, October 1, 2019.
  6. Grand Lodge of British Columbia and Yukon, Successful Lodge Practices, 2013.
  7. Andrew Hammer, Eight Steps to Excellence: The Observant Lodge, 2011.
  8. Ian A. Stewart, At the Masonic Lodge, Gen Z Is in Charge Now, California Freemason, December 12, 2022.
  9. Masons of California, The Leader, October 2024.
  10. Masons of California, 2025 Fraternity Report.
  11. Masons of California, 2024 Fraternity Report: Doors Open.
  12. Pennsylvania Freemason, DeMolays Embracing Masonry, 2025.
JP
John Piccone
Founder, Fraternal Media
Built and maintained the Grand Lodge of Colorado website from 2021 to 2025 and served three years as Chairman of Education. More than a decade in commercial digital marketing through Media Saga, now applied to the fraternal world. Read the story behind Fraternal Media.

Make Your Lodge One of the Growing Ones

We help lodges answer every inquiry, stay in touch with their members, and be found in their towns. If your lodge is ready to build these habits, we should talk.

Start a Conversation